What Cigarette Flavour Poppers Taste Most Like Menthol Cigarettes

What Cigarette Flavour Poppers Taste Most Like Menthol Cigarettes

Menthol cigarettes have long been a favourite among smokers who enjoy a cool, refreshing smoking experience. As regulations, availability, and personal preferences change, many smokers are turning to cigarette flavour poppers (also known as cigarette crush balls or flavour capsules) to recreate that familiar menthol taste.

But not all flavour poppers are created equal. Some come very close to the classic menthol cigarette flavour, while others offer a cooler, sweeter, or more intense twist. In this guide, we’ll break down which cigarette flavour poppers taste most like menthol cigarettes and how to choose the right one for your preferences.

Why Smokers Look for Menthol-Like Cigarette Poppers

Menthol cigarettes deliver a distinctive combination of:

  • Cooling sensation in the throat

  • Clean, fresh aftertaste

  • Mild sweetness without overpowering flavour

  • Smooth inhale compared to regular cigarettes

Cigarette flavour poppers allow smokers to replicate these qualities without switching cigarette brands, giving them control over flavour strength and timing.

Classic Menthol Flavour Poppers: The Closest Match

If your goal is to replicate a traditional menthol cigarette as closely as possible, classic menthol cigarette poppers are the best choice.

What They Taste Like

  • Crisp, clean menthol

  • Cooling effect similar to factory menthol cigarettes

  • Minimal sweetness

  • Familiar “menthol bite” on inhale

Best For

  • Former menthol cigarette smokers

  • Users who want a traditional experience

  • First-time flavour capsule users

Classic menthol poppers are designed to mimic the balance found in menthol cigarette filters, making them the safest option if you want authenticity.

Ice Menthol & Extra Cool Poppers: Stronger Than Traditional Menthol

Some smokers prefer a menthol hit that feels colder and more intense than standard menthol cigarettes. This is where ice menthol or extra cool flavour capsules come in.

What They Taste Like

  • Sharper cooling sensation

  • Stronger throat hit

  • Slightly longer-lasting freshness

How They Compare to Menthol Cigarettes

These poppers go beyond traditional menthol cigarettes. While they still taste “menthol-like,” the cooling effect is amplified. Many users describe them as closer to double menthol or ultra menthol styles.

Mint vs Menthol: A Subtle but Important Difference

Mint-flavoured cigarette poppers are often confused with menthol, but they are not identical.

Mint Poppers Taste Like:

  • Sweeter and greener than menthol

  • Less sharp cooling sensation

  • More herbal flavour notes

If you are specifically trying to recreate the taste of menthol cigarettes, menthol-labelled poppers will feel more authentic than mint-only options.

Menthol + Mild Mint Blends: A Balanced Alternative

Some flavour capsules combine menthol with a light mint undertone. These blends are ideal for smokers who want something very close to menthol, but slightly smoother.

Why Smokers Like These Blends

  • Softer cooling sensation

  • Less harsh than pure menthol

  • Still recognisably menthol-forward

These poppers are often preferred by smokers transitioning away from strong menthol cigarettes.

What Makes Some Menthol Poppers Taste More “Real” Than Others?

Several factors affect how closely a flavour popper matches menthol cigarettes:

  • Flavour oil quality – Higher-quality oils taste cleaner and less artificial

  • Capsule freshness – Fresh capsules release stronger, truer flavour

  • Oil concentration – Balanced formulas mimic cigarette filters better

  • Capsule shell thickness – Controls how quickly flavour is released

Premium cigarette flavour poppers are usually closer to authentic menthol cigarette taste because they focus on balance rather than overpowering intensity.

How to Use Menthol Poppers for the Most Authentic Experience

To make your cigarette flavour poppers taste more like menthol cigarettes:

  1. Insert one capsule per cigarette

  2. Crush it after a few puffs, not immediately

  3. Avoid overusing multiple capsules at once

  4. Store poppers in a cool, dry place

This method mimics how menthol flavour gradually develops in factory-made menthol cigarettes.

Best Menthol-Style Cigarette Poppers for First-Time Users

If you’re new to cigarette flavour capsules and want a menthol-like taste:

  • Start with classic menthol poppers

  • Avoid “ice” or “extra cool” at first

  • Use one capsule only

  • Experiment gradually

All Star Poppers offers menthol options designed to closely match the traditional menthol cigarette profile while still allowing flexibility.


Back to blog

Shop All Star Poppers

View all